These photos show the coffins of victims of a boat disaster in 2013

Copyright AFP 2017-2020. All rights reserved.

Photographs shared hundreds of times online purport to show the coffins of Italian victims of the novel coronavirus pandemic. The claim is false; the pictures date back to October 2013 when hundreds drowned in a boat tragedy in the Mediterranean. 

The photos have been circulating on Facebook and Twitter in various countries, including Australia, Pakistan and South Africa. 

“Still think corona is a joke????” reads the caption on one Facebook post, shared more than 190 times since it was published on March 23.

The accompanying photos show rows of coffins lined up in a warehouse-style building, as bystanders look on. 

Screenshot of the misleading claim shared on Facebook, taken on March 26, 2020

The photographs have been widely shared alongside pleas to “protect your families” or “stay home” to curb the virus, which has killed more than 20,000 people and forced one third of the world’s population into lockdown.

Boat disaster

AFP ran a reverse image search and traced the three photographs circulating on social media to news reports from October 2013, when more than 360 people died after their boat capsized near the Italian island of Lampedusa.

The mostly Eritrean victims were among approximately 500 African migrants travelling on a boat heading for the shores of Europe.

Since 2014, more than 20,000 people have died while making the perilous Mediterranean crossing, according to the UN’s International Organization for Migration.

The first of the three photographs in the montage was taken by Italian photographer Roberto Salomone on October 9, 2013. According to AFP archives, the picture shows Italy’s then-prime minister Enrico Letta and Lampedusa’s mayor Giusy Nicolini standing by coffins of victims of the disaster.

Screenshots from the false posts circulating on social media (left) and the original photograph (right)

The second image was captured by AFP photographer Alberto Pizzoli. He said he was shocked to learn his picture was being shared in a “fake” context.

“This image was taken in Lampedusa on October 5, 2013. I was there and I remember that place, which is an airport hangar,” he told AFP Fact Check.

Screenshots from the false posts circulating on social media (left) and the original photograph (right)

AFP traced the third photo to the archives of news agency Reuters. It was taken by photographer Antonio Parrinello on October 5, 2013, also in a hangar of Lampedusa airport.

Screenshots from the false posts circulating on social media (left) and the original photograph (right)

Some of the misleading posts also include captions claiming that Italy is “running out of coffins” and struggling to cope with demand for cremations.

“Cremation takes about an hour meaning only 24 bodies a day not, just a drop in the ocean (sic),” the caption reads.

Screenshot of part of a misleading post shared on Facebook, taken on March 26, 2020

More than 8,100 people have died from COVID-19 in Italy, making it the country with the most reported deaths from the disease.

A journalist from AFP’s Rome bureau said claims that Italy could only cremate 24 bodies per day were “fanciful”, as the country has a large number of cremation facilities. 

The Altair Spa group, which runs 17 cremation facilities in north-central Italy, covering the worst-hit areas, said on Facebook on March 24 that the situation was “difficult” but “still manageable with professionalism and seriousness”.

AFP reported that the flood of victims has forced the city of Bergamo in Italy’s northern epicentre of the pandemic to send bodies to less burdened crematoriums in neighbouring towns.

Italian newspaper La Reppublica published a photograph of army trucks transporting coffins out of Bergamo’s cemetery last week. 

"The large number of victims has meant that Bergamo’s crematorium could not cope on its own," mayor Giorgio Gori said in a statement.

AFP has previously debunked social media posts purporting to show the coffins of novel coronavirus victims.

Charlotte Mason