A boy paddles a makeshift craft at the mouth of Manila Bay in March 2019. (AFP / Ted Aljibe)

Misleading photo collage inaccurately compares Manila Bay during different Philippine presidencies

Copyright AFP 2017-2020. All rights reserved.

A photo collage has been shared hundreds of times in multiple Facebook and Twitter posts claiming to highlight the contrast in Manila Bay, a harbour in the Philippine capital, during the presidencies of former leader Benigno Aquino III and Rodrigo Duterte, who is currently in office. The posts circulated following a September 2020 government announcement of a proposed plan to develop an artificial white sand beach on the bay. However, the claim is false; the posts contain inaccurate descriptions of the photos' time and location.

The collage was shared more than 100 times after being posted here on Facebook on September 7, 2020.

The photo at the top shows a trash-filled beach next to an image of former Philippine President Benigno Aquino III. Tagalog text overlaid in the image states: "NO ONE COMPLAINED". 

The photo at the bottom shows a clean beach alongside an image of current President Rodrigo Duterte, with Tagalog text that reads: "BOMBARDED WITH COMPLAINTS". 

A screenshot of the misleading post, taken on September 9, 2020

The post’s Tagalog caption reads: "07 September 2020 / WHY DID ERIN TAÑADA NOT COMPLAIN WHEN MANILA BAY WAS A GARBAGE DUMP?"

Tañada, a former legislator and member of the opposition Liberal Party, is among those who criticised a recent government announcement that proposed the development of an artificial white sand beach in Manila Bay. 

The collage was also shared alongside a similar claim here, here, here and here on Facebook; and here, here and here on Twitter.

The claim, however, is false.

Photo of trash-filled beach

The first photo, which shows a beach strewn with rubbish, was not taken during the Aquino III presidency.

A reverse image search on Google traced the photo to this Philippine Star report that states it was taken in the aftermath of a September 2018 typhoon. 

Aquino III left office in 2016 and was succeeded by Duterte, as AFP reported here.  

Below is a screenshot comparison showing the first image in the misleading posts (L) and the Philippine Star photo (R):

Screenshot comparison showing the first image in the misleading posts (L) and the Philippine Star photo (R)

The same photo also circulated in another misleading collage, which was debunked by AFP here

Photo of clean beach 

The second photo of a clean beach was also not taken following the September 2020 announcement of a proposed white sand beach at Manila Bay.

Reverse image and keyword searches found the photo has circulated since at least February 2019 in multiple posts about a Manila Bay clean-up; for example on Facebook here, on Reddit here and on Imgur here.  

Below is a screenshot comparison showing the second image in the misleading posts (L) and the February 2019 Facebook photo (R):

Screenshot comparison showing the second image in the misleading posts (L) and the photo in a February 2019 Facebook post (R)

Photos not from same location

Moreover, the photos were not taken at the same location at Manila Bay.

The first photo corresponds to this Google Maps street view imagery of the Manila Baywalk, a seaside promenade overlooking Manila Bay. The Manila Baywalk is where the government said it would develop the proposed artificial white sand beach. 

Meanwhile, the second photo was taken here at Baseco beach, more than three kilometres northwest of the site of the proposed project. 

A screenshot of Google Maps showing the locations where the photos were taken