Analysis piece from 2018 sparks misinformation about Nigeria's debt to China
Nigeria's growing debt to China has sparked a wave of misinformation about how much money the country owes Beijing. A viral Instagram post made several claims, including that Nigeria had borrowed 3 trillion naira ($7.9 billion). But the allegations are inaccurate and a recycled version of an old Facebook post. The claims are most likely based on misleading figures in an analysis piece published by Nigeria's International Centre for Investigative Reporting in 2018.
Africa's largest economy is facing growing debt to fund key projects following a recession in 2016. But the loans have sparked controversy as Nigeria's Chinese debt has more than doubled in the past four years, with critics accusing the government of selling the country to Beijing.
Popular Nigerian celebrity manager Soso Soberekon published several claims about Nigeria’s debt on Instagram on July 29, 2020.
They included an allegation that Nigeria's President Muhammadu Buhari had borrowed $6 billion from China for infrastructure projects.
The post went viral after renowned Nigerian entertainer Tunde Ednut reposted it to his 2.4 million followers on the social network. It had received more than 50,000 likes by August 8, 2020.
Soberekon's post was published on the same day as national media reported that Nigerian lawmakers had expressed concern over a loan agreement worth $328 million signed between Nigeria and China.
AFP Fact Check found a near-identical version of the claims published on Facebook in 2018 when President Buhari visited Beijing in China. The post was shared nearly 2,000 times.
The claims appear to be based on an analysis piece published by the International Centre for Investigative Reporting (ICIR) on September 4, 2018. It alleged that every Nigerian owed China 15,000 naira ($40).
The report was picked up the next day by Nigerian daily newspaper Daily Trust. However, AFP Fact Check found that the ICIR piece makes a series of misleading or false assertions.
Although Nigeria is indebted to China, the amounts have been exaggerated.
Claim: Nigeria owes China 3 trillion naira. FALSE
AFP Fact Check found that Nigeria's Chinese debt exceeded $3 billion for the first time in 2019, as shown in the table below.
Claim: Nigeria borrowed $3.1 billion from China. MISLEADING
Available records from the state-owned debt agency show $3.1 billion is equivalent to the sum of outstanding loans Nigeria obtained from the Chinese Exim Bank as of March 31, 2020.
However, AFP Fact Check found that the claim had circulated online since September 2018 -- a year before official figures revealed Nigeria's Chinese loan topped $3 billion.
Claim: Nigeria under Buhari borrowed $6.1 billion from China. FALSE
Recent social media posts, including this one on Facebook, claim that Nigeria has borrowed $6 billion from China since Buhari’s presidency began in 2015.
It matches a claim in the ICIR piece, which alleges that “the debt comes from two huge tranches of aid from China: $3.1 billion in 2014 and $6 billion for infrastructure in the last three years”.
But AFP Fact Check found that Nigeria neither borrowed $3.1 billion in 2014 from China under then-president Goodluck Jonathan nor accumulated $6 billion in debt since Buhari took power.
According to Nigeria’s debt agency, China has disbursed a total of $3.3 billion in loans to Nigeria, including $2.59 billion lent to the African country since 2015.
Official records and a Chinese-loans-to-Africa database by researchers at Johns Hopkins University also provide no evidence that Nigeria received a loan from China in 2014.
Claim: Nigeria borrowed $322 million from China in 2018. MISLEADING
AFP Fact Check found no public evidence to support the claim that Nigeria had borrowed $322 million from China in 2018.
Contacted by AFP Fact Check, the author of the 2018 ICIR report acknowledged his findings were not based on official figures but a news story stating that China had offered Nigeria $6 billion. The story did not mention that Nigeria had accepted the money.
"I didn't check the website of the Debt Management Office (DMO) to find out," Theophilus Abbah said. "I quoted the figures from previous research I conducted."
Controversial loan clause
The latest debate was sparked in late July when MPs discovered a clause in a 2018 loan agreement that allegedly concedes Nigeria's sovereignty to China in case of default on repayment.
Please and please, Help me beg Nigeria Government not to sell us to China because of their selfish interests.https://t.co/j0BsxctbWl— EPE HIGH CHIEF 🇳🇬🇿🇦🇲🇺🇪🇪 (@moibiopeyemi) April 15, 2020
However, legal analysts and government officials have rejected the accusation as baseless.
“These kinds of clauses are standard when entering into a contract with a government or government agency,” Ilias Kazeem, a partner at Lagos-based law firm Sholias Legal Practitioners, told AFP Fact Check.
“It is to ensure that any binding award that a commercial party may obtain following a dispute with the government or government agency will be enforceable against the assets of the government or government agency anywhere in the world, provided that other conditions of foreign enforcement of awards are also satisfied.”
Transport Minister Rotimi Amaechi said Nigeria only agreed that China could recover the borrowings in the case of a default by taking back or selling Nigeria’s assets that were laid down as guarantees in the loan contract.
“What you do is, you give a sovereign guarantee and that guarantee is the immunity clause they are talking about,” Amaechi said in a television broadcast on July 31, 2020. “They are saying if you are not able to pay, don’t stop us from taking back those items that will make us recover our funds.”
“The Chinese can never... become president or minister. And if the assets you put down become depreciated, then you negotiate which assets they can go after. Chinese will never take over what was not constructed with the loan.”
*Nigeria's official exchange rate of 379 naira per dollar was used unless stated otherwise.