Video shows Biden gesturing to crowd, not embracing 'imaginary' person

  • This article is more than one year old.
  • Published on December 22, 2023 at 18:10
  • 3 min read
  • By Bill MCCARTHY, AFP USA
Social media users are claiming a video shows Joe Biden reaching to shake hands with and hug an "imaginary" or "invisible" person after a December 2023 speech in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. This is false; the clip is cut short and closely cropped, obscuring the crowd to which the US president was gesturing.

"After shaking hands with invisible people several times, US President Joe Biden started hugging them," says a December 21, 2023 post on X, formerly Twitter, from a popular account called "S p r i n t e r."

"Biden shook hands with his imaginary friend again," the same profile, which has previously spread disinformation under aliases such as "Sprinter," added in a second post.

Image
Screenshot from X taken December 21, 2023
Image
Screenshot from X taken December 21, 2023

 

 

The short clip shows Biden lifting his hands as he looks to his left and then behind him after delivering a speech.

But posts claiming Biden was trying to engage an "imaginary" or "invisible" person are inaccurate.

They are the latest in a long history of manipulated or misrepresented videos purporting to show the Democratic president, 81, lost or confused, misreading social cues or dozing off on the job.

The latest clip captures the conclusion of Biden's December 20, 2023 address to the Wisconsin Black Chamber of Commerce in Milwaukee.

Other angles from the official White House stream and footage from C-SPAN and other US media show audience members seated around the stage as Biden spoke about his administration's economic policies and support for Black-owned small businesses (archived here, here, here and here).

The attendees stood up as Biden stepped away from the podium and turned toward them. He gestured in their direction -- rather than reaching for an "imaginary" person -- and continued to acknowledge different sections of the crowd while exiting the stage.

AFP photos from the event also show the audience.

Image
US President Joe Biden speaks on his economic policies at the Wisconsin Black Chamber of Commerce in Milwaukee, Wisconsin on December 20, 2023 ( AFP / Mandel NGAN)
Image
US President Joe Biden speaks on his economic policies at the Wisconsin Black Chamber of Commerce in Milwaukee, Wisconsin on December 20, 2023 ( AFP / Mandel NGAN)

 

 

AFP contacted the White House for comment, but no response was forthcoming.

AFP has debunked similar claims that Biden waved to no one after other speeches here and here.

Is there content that you would like AFP to fact-check? Get in touch.

Contact us