False claim circulates online that Australian government cut funding for New South Wales fire service in 2020
Multiple posts shared hundreds of times on Facebook and Twitter claim the Australian government cut AUD 200 million from the New South Wales Rural Fire Service (NSW RFS) in the state’s 2020-21 budget. The claim is false; NSW RFS told AFP that budget documents show government funding for the fire service has actually increased for 2020-21.
The misleading claim was published here in a Facebook post on November 17, 2020.
The image in the post reads: “Hidden in the NSW budget, the Liberals have cut $200 million from the Rural Fire Service. Unbelievable.”
The amount AUD 200 million is equivalent to $146 million.
The claim circulated after Australia suffered a particularly devastating bushfire season from September 2019 to early 2020, with parts of New South Wales intensely affected.
The claim is false.
In response to the posts, a New South Wales Rural Fire Service spokesperson told AFP by email on November 18, 2020, that “the claim is not true.”
Great to see another record budget for the #NSWRFS. An additional $148.2 million will be spent in key areas of firefighter mental health, protective clothing, new and improved trucks, and enhancements to Fires Near Me. Important funding to support our volunteers and community— Rob Rogers (@robrfs) November 18, 2020
It states: “Great to see another record budget for the #NSWRFS. An additional $148.2 million will be spent in key areas of firefighter mental health, protective clothing, new and improved trucks, and enhancements to Fires Near Me. Important funding to support our volunteers and community”.
As per the footnotes in this NSW 2020-21 budget document, the NSW RFS’s budget was increased by AUD 148.2 million ($108.3 million) after a catastrophic 2019-20 bushfire season.
“NSW RFS 2019-20 Original Budget was $524.3 million. The 2019-20 summer bushfires led to a significantly higher Natural Disaster Response and Recovery expenditure, with a significant portion within NSWRFS. Compared with the 2019-20 Budget, the NSWRFS budget has increased by $148.2 million in 2020-21,” reads the footnote.
Below is a screenshot of the relevant section in the document, highlighted by AFP:
A table on page 20 of the same document shows that the NSW RFS was originally allocated AUD 524.3 million ($383 million) for 2019-20, but its estimated actual expenditure was AUD 867.2 million ($633.5 million).
The same table shows the NSW RFS budget for 2020-21 is AUD 672.5 million ($491.3 million), thus an increase of AUD 148.2 million compared to the previous year’s allocation.
Below is a screenshot of the table:
Dr Michelle Cull, senior lecturer of accounting from the University of Western Sydney, also refuted the claim. "The budget has actually increased," she told AFP by phone on November 20, 2020.
UPDATE: This article was updated on November 20 to include a quote from Dr Michelle Cull.