These photos of the Philippines have been shared in a misleading context

Copyright AFP 2017-2021. All rights reserved.

Multiple photo collages featuring sites in the Philippines have been shared more than 100,000 times in Facebook and Twitter posts. The posts purport to contrast the locations in years before Rodrigo Duterte was elected president in 2016 with their improvements since he came into office. The photos have been shared in a misleading context; the posts contain inaccurate descriptions about when and where the photos were taken.

The photos were shared in this Facebook post published on April 8, 2020. The post has been shared almost 140,000 times.

The post includes four sets of photo collages. It purports to highlight the comparisons of four locations in the Philippines before and after Duterte’s presidential election victory in May 2016.

The post's caption states: “Our president is a good leader..”

A screenshot of the misleading post by Facebook user Jayson Balbuena Gamba taken on June 4, 2020

The same photos were also shared on Facebook here, and on Twitter here and here alongside a similar claim.

The photos have been shared in a misleading context. 

Manila Bay

The first photo juxtaposition is overlaid with text that reads: “Manila Bay”, referring to a harbour off Manila, the capital of the Philippines.  

The “Before Duterte” photo shows a garbage-filled bay while the “During Duterte” one features a scenic sunset viewed from a clean beach. 

A screenshot of the first set of misleading photo collage taken on June 4, 2020

A combined reverse image and keyword searches on Google found both photos were taken during the Duterte administration. 

The purported “Before Duterte” photo was published in this December 2019 report by Philippine newspaper The Philippine Star and described as showing the aftermath of Typhoon Ompong at Manila Bay. 

The typhoon hit the country in September 2018, during Duterte’s presidency.  

Below is a screenshot comparison showing the miscaptioned image (L) and the Philippine Star photo (R):

Screenshot comparison

The “During Duterte” photo appears in this 2019 report by Philippine news network GMA News about cleanup operations at Manila Bay.

Pasig River

The second photo collage is described as showing the Pasig River, which runs through the Manila metropolitan areas.  

A screenshot of the second set of misleading photo collage taken on June 4, 2020

The photos, however, do not show the Pasig River; instead, they show Estero de Binondo, a creek near Manila’s Chinatown.   

Below is a screenshot comparison of the miscaptioned photos (L and C) and their corresponding location on Google Street View (R):

Screenshot comparison

Philippine National Railways trains

The third set of photos compares old Philippine National Railways (PNR) trains, purportedly in operation before Duterte’s presidency, with new trains that were in operation during his administration.

A screenshot of the third set of misleading photo collage taken on June 4, 2020

But the old trains seen in the “Before Duterte” photos remain in operation to date.

A closer inspection found the train in the top left-hand corner bears the number 919, while the one in the top right is numbered 5001.

Both are “still operational,” Joseline Geronimo, PNR operations manager, told AFP in a text message on June 4, 2020.

The “During Duterte” photo previously appeared in this 2019 Jakarta Post report about the delivery of new PNR trains from an Indonesian manufacturer.

Boracay

The fourth photo comparison is overlaid with text that states: “Boracay”, which is an island known for its beaches and resorts in central Philippines. 

A screenshot of the fourth set of misleading photo collage taken on June 4, 2020

The purported “Before Duterte” photo of an algae-laced beach was in fact taken while Duterte was in office. The second photo showing a pristine beach has actually circulated in online posts before Duterte was elected president.

A reverse image search on Google found the first photo published in this report by Philippine media ABS-CBN, which states it was taken on March 22, 2018, during Duterte’s presidency.

Another reverse image search using TinEye found the “During Duterte” appears uncredited in several web pages before Duterte’s election victory in 2016, for example in 2014 here and in 2015 here

Below are two sets of screenshot comparison between the photos in the misleading posts (L) and their corresponding photos traced through reverse image searches (R):

Screenshot comparison