The purported flag has been doctored from a flag seen at a UK far-right demonstration
An image of two flags has been shared thousands of times in multiple posts on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter which claim it shows the similarities between a “new Antifa flag” and a Nazi flag. The claim is false; the image of the purported “Antifa flag” has been doctored from footage of a flag seen at a far-right demonstration in the UK in 2016; experts say antifa is a loosely organised anti-fascist movement that does not have a designated flag.
The image was published on Facebook here on June 18, 2020.
It has been shared more than 300 times after it was shared in a Facebook group "Australians against radical Islam", which has more than 100,000 followers.
The top image features a red flag with a black and white cross. The letters "AF" can be seen at the intersection of the cross.
The text overlaid in the collage reads: “Does the new Antifa flag remind you of anything?”
The collage was shared alongside a similar claim thousands of times here, here, here and here on Facebook; here and here on Twitter; and here on Instagram. It was also shared alongside the same claim in other languages, including here in Spanish.
The collage circulated online in 2017 and 2018, but again gained traction in June 2020 after US President Donald Trump vowed on June 1 to designate the antifa movement as a terrorist organisation. The White House has since repeatedly blamed antifa for the ongoing Black Lives Matter protests and riots, AFP reported here.
The claim in the posts, however, is false.
A reverse image search on Google with the top image found that the purported photo of the “Antifa flag” has been digitally manipulated from footage of a flag at a far-right protest in the UK in 2016.
The video of the original flag was published on YouTube here in January 2016 by Ruptly, the Berlin-based video branch of Russia’s state-owned RT television network.
The video is titled “UK: Violence erupts at National Front and far-right march in Dover, arrests made”. It shows a similar scene as seen in the top image. The person seen dressed in black, however, can be seen holding a flag with the letters "NF", not "AF".
Below is a screenshot comparison of the top image in the misleading post (L) and the 2016 Ruptly video (R) with the key difference circled in yellow by AFP:
While various flags about anti-fascist action have been seen at antifa protests -- as seen in AFP photos here and here -- the movement does not have a designated flag or emblem because it is not an organised group.
“Antifa is a politics or activity not a group. In general the most common images that antifa groups tend to use are the flags [seen here and here],” Mark Bray, a historian and the author of “Antifa: The Anti-Fascist Handbook”, told AFP in a June 27 email.
Associate Professor Stanislav Vysotsky, a sociologist whose research focuses on fascist and anti-fascist movements, also said in an email to AFP dated June 30: "Because the antifascist movement is decentralised, there is no official flag or symbol. There is some consistency in the use of the overlapping flag symbol of Antifascist Action or the three arrows of the Iron Front, but this is not official in any way, and there is a great variety of symbolism used by antifa activists."
Dr. Mark Pitcavage, a historian and expert on extremism in the US, said the bottom image shows a Nazi flag.
“The other flag in question is a Reichskriegsflagge (military flag or war ensign) from the Nazi era. This was a military flag used by the various armed forces of Nazi Germany between 1935 and 1945,” he told AFP. “Ostensibly Hitler himself designed the flag.”