No, this video does not show passengers aboard an Indonesian Lion Air plane moments before it crashed
- This article is more than one year old.
- Published on November 1, 2018 at 18:00
- 3 min read
Copyright © AFP 2017-2025. Any commercial use of this content requires a subscription. Click here to find out more.
Lion Air Flight JT 610 crashed into the Java Sea shortly after take off on Monday October 29 with 189 people on board. There were no survivors.
Within hours of the plane going missing a video began circulating online claiming to show passengers inside a darkened cabin calling out: “Allahu akbar”, or “God is greater”, and other Islamic verses as the plane apparently was out of control.
AFP has tracked down dozens of Facebook pages that have posted the video with claims it was from the crashed Lion Air plane, including @SpotLightHumanity where it has been viewed more than 1.3 million times.
It has also been viewed more than 220,000 times on an Arabic blogger’s page, 100,000 times on a Pakistani celebrity pics page, and a combined 100,000 times on two aviation pages: @Airplane4 and @Airplane13.
Among news outlets, Russia Today posted the video on its Arabic Twitter account where it has been viewed more than 90,000 times.
The video also appeared on news websites in Greece, Pakistan, India and Tunisia.
The video went viral despite Indonesian authorities reacting quickly to say it was from a previous Lion Air flight, which did not crash.
Indonesia’s disaster mitigation agency spokesman, Sutopo Purwo Nugroho, said on Twitter on October 29 -- the day of the crash -- that the video was from Lion Air flight JT 353 to Jakarta from Padang, another Indonesian city on an unspecified earlier date.
Video ini BUKAN penumpang pesawat Lion Air JT 610. Tetapi ini penumpang pesawat Lion Air JT 353 Padang-Jakarta yang turbulensi dan semua penumpang selamat beberapa waktu yang lalu. Tidak ada video/foto kondisi penumpang sebelum JT 610 jatuh. Jangan ikut menyebarkan hoax. pic.twitter.com/VbGYaBlVop
— Sutopo Purwo Nugroho (@Sutopo_PN) October 29, 2018
His tweet translates as: “This video IS NOT showing passengers of Lion Air JT 610. This is of passengers of Lion Air JT 353 Padang-Jakarta some time ago which was experiencing turbulence. All passengers were safe. There are no video/photo of JT 610 passengers before the plane crashed. Please don’t spread hoaxes.”
Sutopo did not give details as to where the video originated.
AFP tracked the video’s origin to the private Instagram account @marapi_singgalang.
The Instagram post was accompanied by a lengthy caption which, in part, says: “Deep condolences for the incident experienced by @lionairgroup plane #lionair #lionjt610. This is a video taken by myself on a flight that made me so traumatised I no longer want to travel by plane.”
AFP spoke with David Ditama, who owns the @marapi_singgalang Instagram account, on October 31.
Ditama told AFP he was was aboard the Lion Air JT 353 flight, which was heading to Jakarta from Padang, on December 11, 2017.
Ditama said he took the video from a clip he posted to Twitter on December 13, 2017, and that he re-posted it on Instagram as a way to express his emotions following the crash of JT 610.
Ditama said he made clear in his Instagram post where the video came from, and that he was surprised it had been shared and misrepresented without his permission.
“I don't know who might have circulated the video without my permission and then misused it,” he told AFP.
The original post on Ditama’s Twitter account can be seen below.
Terimakasih Ya Allah...Telah menyelamatkan kami semua setelah di terjang badai 1 jam 30 menit,,JT353 PDG-CGK
— ALGUMARA (@Uda1899) December 13, 2017
Ketika maut terasa dekat di ujung mata. pic.twitter.com/WsedsmTfoZ
Is there content that you would like AFP to fact-check? Get in touch.
Contact us
