French producer Laurent Girard peels black garlic, obtained after cooking garlic using a well-preserved secret recipe, on December 8, 2016 (AFP / Thierry Zoccolan)

There is no evidence that black garlic can prevent cancer, health experts say

This article is more than one year old.
Published on July 31, 2020 at 11:00
3 min read
By AFP Thailand

Multiple posts shared repeatedly on Facebook and Twitter claim that black garlic, a type of aged garlic often used as an ingredient in Asian cuisine, has properties that can decrease the chances of developing cancer "sixfold". The claim is misleading; health experts say there is insufficient scientific evidence that black garlic can prevent cancer; Thailand’s National Cancer Institute warns that excessive consumption of black garlic can result in unwanted side effects.

The post was published here on Facebook on February 22, 2020.

A screenshot of the misleading Facebook post

It reads: “Black garlic prevents cancer by 6 times”.

Black garlic is the process of fermenting garlic in the temperature of 60-90 degree celsius for at least one month until the garlic turns dark, according to this report published by Thailand’s Mahidol University.

A similar claim was also shared here in 2012 and here in 2016. More recently it was shared here and here in 2020 on Facebook.

The claim, however, is false.

Dr. Suebpong Tanasanvimon, an oncology specialist at Chulalongkorn University told AFP there are “no studies which state that eating [black garlic] can prevent” cancer.

During a phone conversation on July 30, he said: "I've never heard of this. There are no clear studies which state that eating a specific thing can prevent you from cancer.

“The reason for most types of cancer is still unknown. However, there are some types of cancer in which we know what causes and how we can prevent them, such as lung cancer which is caused by smoking, or liver cancer which is caused by heavy drinking. However, there are no studies which indicate that certain kinds of food have definite anti-cancer properties.”

Thailand’s state-run National Cancer Institute also called the claims “fake news” in this report published on its website on May 21, 2020.

Part of the Thai-langugage report translates to English as: “Studies have shown that black garlic contains antioxidants in the group of flavonoid and polyphenols which may help prevent cancer cells. However, most of the research involved is only laboratory or experimental animals.”

It also warned against excessive consumption of black garlic, saying: “[People] should consume black garlic products which are up to standard in order to protect from other contaminants. Over consumption may lead to side effects to your health, especially cancer patients who are undergoing treatment should be supervised by a doctor."

Similarly, the US-based American Institute for Cancer Research states here that while certain compounds in garlic are known to “offer anti-cancer activity”, it lacks human study.

It reads in part: “More research is needed to understand how garlic’s role in cancer risk might vary based on the amount, absorption, preparation methods and individual differences. AICR’s Third Expert Report and Continuous Update Project (CUP) found evidence too limited to draw any conclusions about garlic and cancer risk.”

The claim was also debunked by Thailand’s Anti-Fake News Centre, a government-run platform within the Ministry of Digital Economy and Society, here in May 2020.

Is there content that you would like AFP to fact-check? Get in touch.

E-mail

There is no evidence that black garlic can prevent cancer, health experts say

YouTube