Facebook users misrepresent viral video of Brazillian nurses in empty coronavirus ward
A video showing health workers singing in an empty hospital ward has been shared tens of thousands of times on Facebook alongside a claim it portrays the “truth” of the coronavirus pandemic in Brazil. The claim is misleading: the clip shows a wing of a hospital in Brazil, which was treating more than 70 patients for Covid-19 in other wards. In the city where the video was filmed, the occupancy of adult intensive care beds was 93% at the time the video was recorded.
The claims were shared by a New Zealand-based political party Advance NZ here on April 22, 2021. The video has been viewed more than 7,000 times.
The video shows a health worker walking around a hospital ward. She can be seen pulling open the curtains to reveal empty beds, as her co-workers sing a religious song, Porque El Vive ("Because He Lives"), in Portuguese.
Brazil has struggled to contain Covid-19, recording more than 14 million cases since the outbreak began in March 2020, according to Johns Hopkins University statistics.
Despite the situation, the video's caption attempts to cast doubt on Brazil’s coronavirus crisis.
The caption reads: “CNBC reports ‘Covid in Brazil completely out of control’. ‘We have people dying because of lack of oxygen, people are literally suffocating,’ Patricia Campos Mello, a reporter for Folha de Sao Paulo, told CNBC’s ‘The News with Shepard Smith’.
“Meanwhile: A medical team in Brazil decided to praise God and show the truth, empty covid unit beds.”
The claim, however, is misleading.
At the video's 15-second mark, a poster affixed to a computer screen on the hospital ward appears to show the logo for Brazillian medical insurer Unimed.
In response to an AFP request, Unimed said the video was recorded in their Alberto Urquiza Wanderley Hospital. It is situated in the coastal city of João Pessoa, capital of the northeastern Brazillian state of Paraíba.
The video was filmed in one of the hospital’s intensive care units during a night shift from March 30 to 31 in a “momentarily favourable scenario”, a company spokesperson said.
“After an increase in cases of Covid-19, there was a reduction [in cases], which, at that time enabled [this] ICU to be without patients”, the spokesperson told AFP. “The use of this video in any other context that seeks to misrepresent the fact itself is biased and not true.”
The scene shown in the video was only possible, according to Unimed, because the Alberto Urquiza hospital follows a “contingency plan” which means the number of beds in an ICU ward can be increased or decreased depending on the number of patients.
On the day the video was filmed, there were 77 patients with Covid-19 interned in other ICUs at the hospital, and 75 the next day, Unimed told AFP. On April 27, there were 39 patients with Covid-19 in ICU beds at Alberto Urquiza Wanderley.
Brazil virus cases
In contrast to the claims made by Facebook users sharing the video, ICU beds reserved for coronavirus patients in Greater João Pessoa were nearly all occupied at the time the video was filmed.
According to data published by the State Department of Health of Paraíba (SES), 93 percent of ICU beds were occupied in the capital, João Pessoa, while 88 percent of adult ICU beds for Covid-19 were occupied in the state, on March 30.
On March 31, 85 percent of ICU beds reserved for Covid-19 patients in the state were occupied, while 86 percent were occupied in Greater João Pessoa.
The situation, however, in other parts of Brazil remained dire in April. AFP reported on the crisis here.