Experts in India refute misleading claim that China-made Holi festival goods are infected with coronavirus
A claim that Chinese goods imported for the Holi festival in India should be avoided because they are infected with the novel coronavirus has been shared multiple times on Facebook, Twitter and WhatsApp. The claim is misleading; the World Health Organization (WHO) told AFP that the virus does not last long on inanimate surfaces, so it is unlikely imported goods would remain infectious; the Toy Association of India told AFP the virus would not survive on a shipment of Holi festival items as the journey from China generally takes at least two weeks.
Below is a screenshot of the misleading Facebook post:
The post’s Hindi-language caption translates to English as: “The festival of Holi will be celebrated on March 10, where Chinese made items like toy guns, colours, face mask, artificial hair are used heavily. Today, hundreds of thousands of Chinese are affected by Coronavirus. In India, only a couple of cases have been found and in view of the Holi festival, please boycott these Chinese items to safeguard your family and children. Please tell local dealers to avoid buying these items from China. Stay alert, share this message widely and make it viral across India.”
Holi is an Indian festival that signifies the start of spring and is often celebrated by covering people in colored powder.
As of February 26, 2020, the novel coronavirus has killed over 2,700 people and infected more than 80,000 in 34 countries, the vast majority of whom are in China, AFP reported.
This claim is misleading; a regional WHO representative said that the virus does not last long on surfaces of objects, so it is unlikely that imported goods would remain infectious on arrival to India.
“Research as far as we know seems to indicate that the virus does not survive for very long on objects. For toys, the risk is only if the toy is contaminated with the virus and for the toy to be contaminated there are special conditions. So it is very unlikely that a toy will be contaminated with the virus simply because it was manufactured in China," the WHO's representative for India, told AFP by phone on February 24, 2020.
The WHO also issued a similar advisory here on their website that says it is “safe” to receive goods from China.
“People receiving packages from China are not at risk of contracting the new coronavirus. From the previous analysis, we know coronaviruses do not survive long on objects, such as letters or packages," the statement reads.
The Toy Association of India, which oversees imports of toys from China, told AFP it takes an average of two-three weeks for shipments from China to reach India via sea, and it is therefore “highly unlikely” for an object to remain infectious on arrival.
“Factories in China were shut for New Year from the first week of January. The last shipment from China came to India on January 15," Vice President of the Association Vipin Nijhawan added.
This article was updated on March 12 to anonymise the WHO's regional representative in India.