This photo taken on March 18, 2020 shows a mother washing her laundry outside her home along the river in Manila. (AFP / Maria Tan)

Doctored news graphic falsely claims Filipino official branded poor people a ‘burden’ in coronavirus vaccination drive

Copyright AFP 2017-2021. All rights reserved.

A photo repeatedly shared on Facebook purports to show a news graphic containing genuine remarks by a Philippine presidential spokesperson that poor people are a “burden” on the government's coronavirus vaccination efforts. The claim is false: the purported graphic has been doctored to add the fabricated remarks about the poor.

The photo was shared on Facebook here on January 13, 2021. It features an image of Philippine presidential spokesperson Harry Roque

A screenshot of the misleading post, taken on January 15, 2021

The photo’s text overlay states: "I stand with my previous statement that poor people have no right to choose. THEY CAN'T EVEN BUY FOOD, WHAT MORE VACCINES. DON'T BE PICKY BECAUSE YOU ARE POOR AND A BURDEN FOR THE GOVERNMENT. It's your fault you're still poor, you rely on the government for all of your needs. IT'S NOT ALLOWED TO BE PICKY DURING THE TIME OF PANDEMIC / Pres. Spokesperson Harry Roque says Filipinos who avail of the government's free vaccinations cannot choose which vaccine will be used during the immunisation campaign."

The post circulated online shortly after Roque faced criticism for remarks he allegedly made about the Philippines’ Covid-19 vaccination drive. This video from an official briefing on January 11 shows Roque saying Filipinos cannot be “picky” about which coronavirus vaccine they receive. 

Comments from some Facebook users on the post indicate it had misled them. One comment reads: “An insult to poor people. That we don’t have the human right to choose because we are poor.”

Another said: "Legit? he really said that? you have a link this might have been edited".

The image was also shared alongside a similar claim on Facebook here, here, here, here and here

The claim is false.

Keyword searches on Google found the news graphic was originally published here by Philippine media organisation GMA News on January 11, 2021.

The quote in the GMA News graphic reads: "It's true, we have the right to good health but one cannot be picky because there are a lot of Filipinos who need to be vaccinated. One can't be choosy, but one can't also be forced inoculated."

Below is a screenshot comparison of the photo in the misleading posts (L) and the GMA News graphic (R):

Screenshot comparison

The quote in the GMA News graphic corresponds to remarks made by Roque in this January 11 press briefing. An official transcript of the briefing contains no reference to Roque’s purported quote about poor Filipinos, as claimed in the misleading posts. 

Roque’s office also branded the misleading social media posts as “fake news” in this statement posted on Facebook on January 13, 2021. 

Screenshot of statement

The statement placed the doctored news graphic side-by-side another Roque quote that sought to clarify his earlier remarks about vaccination. It states in part: “When the vaccine arrives in February until June, one can’t really be choosy because only one vaccine would be available, and that’s the one from China. If you do not want Sinovac, you won’t be forced to take it.”

Roque made the clarification in this January 12 press briefing, which also does not contain the quote indicated in the doctored graphic.

VACCINS COVID-19