A medical staff member wearing protective gear takes a swab from a visitor to test for the Covid-19 coronavirus at a temporary testing station outside Seoul railway station in Seoul on December 22, 2020. (AFP / Jung Yeon-je)

South Korean officials set to investigate nasal dilator over unproven Covid-19 prevention claim

Copyright AFP 2017-2021. All rights reserved.

Multiple posts circulating on South Korean social media advertise a nasal dilator that can "prevent and kill" Covid-19. However, South Korea’s Ministry of Food and Drug Safety said it was planning to investigate the product, which is certified to protect against bacteria, not viruses.

The misleading claim about the product, named “Kovagi”, was shared here on Facebook on December 21, 2020.

Screenshot of the misleading Facebook post. Captured on January 1, 2021

Part of Korean-language text superimposed on the image translates to English as: “The world's first vaccine that prevents respiratory disease. 

“Prevent and kill. Kovagi launched.

 “Common cold, flu, Covid-19, rhinitis, sinusitis and reduction of snoring.

 “99% antibacterial and deodorisation effectiveness around the nasal area.

 “It's a 'nosesk' [nose+mask] that you can wear while eating or drinking.”

A similar claim has been shared on Facebook here, here and here; and on Korean blog site Naver here.

The claim is misleading. 

Kim Hyun-sun, head of Cyber Investigation Team at South Korea's Ministry of Food and Drug Safety, told AFP it would launch an investigation into the product as the claim in the social media posts was “likely to be false”.

“The product is registered as a nasal dilator; the advertisement is likely to be false, and its claim [about Covid-19] is also likely to be false,” she said during a phone interview on January 6, 2021. “We will launch an investigation on both manufacturer and the product to check their claim, but it will take some time.”

The information on the ministry’s website shows that the product is registered as a medical device and designed to dilate the nasal valves.

Screenshot of the product information on the ministry’s website, circled in red by AFP. Captured on January 7, 2021

The product has acquired a patent from the Korean Intellectual Property Office as a “Snoring Preventing Appliance.”

Below is a screenshot of the device’s patent on the Korean Intellectual Property Office’s website:

Screenshot of the patent information on the office’s website, circled in red by AFP. Captured on January 7, 2021

Kim Byung-yong, a researcher at the Korea Far Infrared Association (KFIA), told AFP that the product had been tested for its effectiveness in protecting the user from bacteria, rather than viruses.

“It is true that KFIA issued a certificate to the manufacturer of the product in February 2019 to confirm its antibacterial effectiveness, but the test was to see its effectiveness against colon bacillus and bacillus pyocyaneus,” he said in a phone interview on January 6, 2021. “Bacteria and viruses are different. Proven antibacterial effectiveness does not mean it’s also effective in preventing Covid-19.”

No evidence that the product is effective in preventing Covid-19 infection is shown on the product’s official website here.

 
Richard Kang
Covid-19